Welcome to Psychic Records, the new evolution of a neighborhood institution. Dive into our diverse collection that spans new and vintage vinyl, CDs, vintage tapes, musical gear, and instrument supplies. Whether you're a collector, a musician, or just a music lover, you're bound to find something that resonates with your taste.

FAQ

Does your record store buy from individuals, and what are your requirements?

Yes! We buy records in good, re-sellable condition!

What specific genres and eras of records are you most interested in?

Interested in ALL genres! However, we do NOT offer money for classical music records under most circumstances.

Are there any record types or conditions you generally do not accept?

We do not buy 78s. 45s should have accompanying picture sleeves if possible. We cannot offer money for records that are unplayable, dirty, or in unsellable condition.

How can someone arrange a time to come in with their records?

Please let me know if you'd like to arrange a time to come in.

Last updated: 2024-05-29

Quick facts

4.6 on Google (167 reviews)
Carries broad CD range plus ample vinyl collection
Features New Age and Jazz sections including fusion and vocals

Will special-order any band's collection if physical media available
Organized by artist name; genres include pop, metal, hip-hop, and local artists
Staff familiar with regular customers and their music preferences
20+ years of consistent inventory and service

Source checked: 2026-07-11

Selling records?

Need help before you contact stores?

Use the seller guide to compare local buyers and send a simple collection request.

Sell vinyl records Seller guide

Stores near Psychic Records

Title	City	Distance
Fifth Avenue Record Shop	New York	0 miles
CWW RADIO SHOP	New York	2 miles
Buzzed Monkey Records	Brooklyn	2 miles
Finer Sounds	New York	2 miles
African Record Center Ltd	Brooklyn	2 miles

Nearby Cities: Brooklyn, New York City, Bensonhurst, East New York, Long Island City, Coney Island, Hoboken, Jersey City, Bayonne, Weehawken