Record store: Randy Now's Man Cave

We buy from individuals. You can bring them by anytime—we'll look for condition and desirability of title. It might take a little time to go through many LPs to determine a fair price, so feel free to grab a coffee while you wait.


What specific genres and types of records are you looking for?

We're mainly looking for:

  • Heavy Metal (e.g., Slayer, Metallica, Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin)
  • All types of metal, including Swedish, gloom, stoner, dark metal, and black metal
  • Punk rock, from Dead Kennedys to new bands
  • Emo
  • Any psychedelic or garage 60's stuff
  • Classic rock bands like The Beatles, The Stones, The Kinks, Yes, The Who, Pink Floyd, Nirvana
  • Mile Davis, John Coltrane, and any Blue Note jazz records
  • New Wave from the 80s
  • Labels such as Apple Records, Sun Records, Stiff Records, Third Man Records

What condition do the records need to be in?

Buyers only want super clean vinyl—no names written on covers, no deep scratches, and LP covers not split on top or bottom. If an LP came with extras like posters or insert lyric sheets, they all help increase the value.

Are there any types of records you do not need?

We do not need records by Barry Manilow, Barbra Streisand, most Broadway soundtracks, or Sergio Mendes.

When is the best time to bring in records? Do I need an appointment?

I'm in from Wednesday through Sunday. Honestly, no appointment is needed, and I can zip through quickly. I have a collection of 300 LP's coming in today to look at, but any time after today is wide open.

Hope I didn't scare you away! LOL!


Contact the store

record store address: 15 East Park Street, Bordentown, NJ 08505, USA