Fifth Avenue Record Shop

Fifth Avenue Record Shop in Brooklyn is a cramped, dusty space packed with records stacked everywhere. It's the kind of place where hunting takes patience—hours of digging through disorganized bins to uncover unexpected finds. The shop stocks an eclectic range of music across formats, though tracking down a specific title isn't guaranteed. Hours are inconsistent, so call ahead at 929-295-0566 before heading over.

Outside, overflowing dollar bins and 50-cent crates offer deep discounts on vinyl. This is old-school cratedigging: messy, inconvenient, and deliberately chaotic. If you have time to spend and don't mind the disorder, you'll probably walk out with records you didn't know you wanted. Reach out at tonymrecords@aol.com or check their Instagram for updates.

Last updated: 2026-06-07