Midnite Moon

Midnite Moon is a small mountain-town shop in Idyllwild that grew out of Ephemera but quickly became its own pop-culture world. Jennifer's answers show a store built for locals, visitors, collectors, and casual browsers: vinyl, movies, games, books, nostalgia, and the kind of unexpected finds that make a small shop feel alive.

Interview with Midnite Moon

What’s the story behind Midnite Moon up in Idyllwild, and what would a regular tell a newcomer you’re about?

Midnite Moon opened in 2023 as the little sister to my vintage shop, Ephemera, but it very quickly developed an identity all its own. Music has run through my entire life, so I wanted to create something that felt like more than a traditional record store. It’s an immersive little world filled with vinyl, movies, video games, books and pieces of pop-culture history—nostalgic, colorful, a little weird and constantly surprising. I think a regular would tell a newcomer that you can come in looking for one record and lose an hour exploring everything else.

You’re a small shop in a mountain town rather than a big-city store — how does that setting shape what you stock and who wanders in?

Being in a small mountain town means I can’t - and don’t really want to - stock for only one kind of collector. We have local regulars, serious music people, teenagers discovering vinyl for the first time and visitors who walk in while exploring town. That creates a really broad and fun mix: foundational albums people always want, current releases, indie exclusives, soundtracks, unusual pressings and plenty of things people didn’t know they needed until they saw them. The store has to feel accessible to a casual browser while still giving a knowledgeable collector something worth digging for.

Idyllwild’s a tucked-away arts community in the San Jacintos — who comes through, and how’s the scene up there?

Idyllwild may be tucked away, but it has an incredible concentration of artists, musicians and wonderfully unconventional people. We get weekenders escaping the cities, hikers, climbers, families, collectors and people who came up for the trees and unexpectedly found this strange little record shop upstairs. The creative community here is very interconnected, and music is a huge part of it. There are always shows, art events and people making something. It’s small enough that relationships really matter, but eclectic enough that you never quite know who will walk through the door. I have been surprised many, many times. 😊

What’s the most valuable or surprising record that’s come through the door?

I bought a huge collection of 70s/80s industrial, punk, and experimental music from a woman who just walked in one day with her own 4-box collection. Some of these lps, like one sealed from Zoviet France, were extremely rare. It was fascinating to go through the music because I had never heard 80% of it! She and I became friends and she shared stories of the shows she went to and experiences discovering these bands way back then. I think the most valuable part of buying records is the people I buy them from. I absolutely love talking with people about their musical experiences and enjoy getting to know them. It enriches my life in ways I cannot even express. The whole process for me is magical.

When someone brings in records to sell, how do you approach valuing them?

The first thing is identifying exactly what we’re looking at, because two copies of the same album can have completely different values. I consider the pressing, condition of both the vinyl and sleeve, rarity, current demand and actual recent sales - not simply what someone has listed it for online. I also have to consider whether it fits our customers and how quickly it is likely to sell. I try to be fair and transparent about the fact that resale value isn’t the same as a store’s purchase price. We’re taking on the cleaning, grading, research, storage and risk involved in eventually finding the right buyer.

Roughly what does a common record fetch versus something you’re genuinely excited to buy?

A common used record in sellable condition generally retails for around $5-$20 which means our buying price has to leave room for the work and risk involved in reselling it. When something genuinely scarce, desirable and in beautiful condition comes through, that can move into the tens, hundreds or occasionally much more. There isn’t one automatic price for a “rare” record—the exact pressing, condition and current demand determine everything.

Beyond LPs, do 45s and 78s ever turn up in a mountain town like this, and do they sell?

They do turn up, especially when someone brings in an older family collection. There can be a market for 45s—particularly desirable rock, soul, punk, unusual picture sleeves or anything with strong collector interest. The market for 78s is much more specialized. Most are not especially valuable, and they’re incredibly condition-sensitive, but rare blues, early jazz, country and other historically significant recordings can absolutely be exciting. Though, we honestly don’t purchase a ton of 78s. They move more slowly than LPs, but the right one will always find its person.

What do people most often get wrong about what their records are worth?

The biggest misconception is that age automatically equals value. It doesn’t. Scarcity, demand, pressing and condition all have to meet in the same record. People also see an outrageous asking price online and assume that is what their copy is worth, without checking whether one has ever actually sold for that amount. Beatles and Elvis records are classic examples: some editions are extremely valuable, but millions of others were pressed. A record can be emotionally priceless and commercially worth five dollars - both things can be true at once.

FAQ

What is Midnite Moon?

Midnite Moon is an Idyllwild shop carrying vinyl, movies, video games, books, and pop-culture history.

Does Midnite Moon buy records?

Yes. Jennifer looks at pressing, vinyl and sleeve condition, rarity, demand, recent sales, and fit for the shop’s customers.

Are old records automatically valuable?

No. Jennifer points out that age alone does not create value; scarcity, demand, pressing, and condition all matter.

Last updated: 2026-08-21

Store owners

Add a VinylPackman badge

Use this small badge on a Press, About, Links, or News page to point visitors back to the feature.

Show badge code

Need to fix store details?

Owner or staff? Send a correction for review.

Correct this listing