Mr Cheapo CDs & Records
Record store in Commack, NY
Mr Cheapo CDs & Records in Commack carries new and used vinyl records, CDs, cassettes, DVDs, Blu-rays, and video games across multiple genres including rock, jazz, hip-hop, reggae, classical, and garage. The store also stocks turntables, merchandise like t-shirts and hats, books, and music memorabilia. Located at 2020 Jericho Turnpike in the Mayfair Shopping Center, Mr Cheapo has built a loyal customer base since opening its Commack location, drawing collectors and music fans from around the world.
The store hosts events and offers mail-order shopping for customers unable to visit in person. Mr Cheapo's inventory spans all formats and genres, with staff dedicated to quality merchandise. The business was founded in 1981 by Stu Goldberg, who began collecting records from garage sales and flea markets. The Commack location joined an earlier Mineola store, establishing Mr Cheapo as a well-known destination for music collectors and casual listeners across Long Island.
Last updated: 2026-06-07
Selling records?
Need help before you contact stores?
Use the seller guide to compare local buyers and send a simple collection request.
Stores near Mr Cheapo CDs & Records
| Title | City | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Dancejock Productions Ltd | Deer Park | 6 miles |
| FYE [Lake Grove] | Lake Grove | 7 miles |
| Vitamin Vintage Vinyl | Huntington | 8 miles |
| Hideaway Vinyl | Huntington | 9 miles |
| Record Reserve | Huntington | 9 miles |
Nearby Cities: Commack, Kings Park, Elwood, East Northport, Smithtown, Hauppauge, Dix Hills, Village of the Branch, Brentwood, Fort Salonga